Len Dawson
- Quarterback
- Pittsburgh Steelers
- Cleveland Browns
- Dallas Texans
- Kansas City Chiefs
- 1957-1975
Jackie Smith
- Tight End
- St. Louis Cardinals
- Dallas Cowboys
- 1963-1978
Ted Hendricks
- Outside Linebacker
- Baltimore Colts
- Oakland Raiders
- Green Bay Packers
- 1969-1983
Ron Mix
- Offensive Tackle
- San Diego Chargers
- Oakland Raiders
- 1960-1971
James Lofton
- Wide Receiver
- Green Bay Packers
- Los Angeles Raiders
- Buffalo Bills
- Philadelphia Eagles
- Los Angeles Rams
- 1978-1993
Paul Krause
- Defensive Back
- Washington Redskins
- Minnesota Vikings
- 1964-1979
George McAfee
Halfback/Defensive Back
Chicago Bears
1940, 1941, 1946-1950
Chuck Bednarik
- Linebacker/Center
- Philadelphia Eagles
- 1949-1962
Bobby Mitchell
- Running Back/Receiver
- Cleveland Browns
- Washington Redskins
- 1958-1968
YA Tittle
- Quarterback
- Baltimore Colts
- San Francisco 49ers
- New York Giants
- 1948-1964
Bruce Smith
- Defensive End
- Buffalo Bills
- Washington Redskins
- 1985-2003
Richard Dent
- Defensive End
- Chicago Bears
- San Francisco 49ers
- Indianapolis Colts
- Philadelphia Eagles
- 1983-1997
Johnny Robinson
- Defensive Back
- Dallas Texans/Kansas City Chiefs
- 1960-1972
Larry Little
- Guard
- San Diego Chargers
- Miami Dolphins
- 1967-1980
Eric Dickerson
- Running Back
- Los Angeles Rams
- Indianapolis Colts
- Los Angeles Raiders
- Atlanta Falcons
- 1983-1993
Marion Motley
- Fullback
- Cleveland Browns
- Pittsburgh Steelers
- 1946-1955
Rickey Jackson
- Linebacker
- New Orleans Saints
- San Francisco 49ers
- 1981-1995
Red Grange
- Running Back/Defensive Back
- Chicago Bears
- New York Yankees
- 1925-1934