Vai Sikahema
- Kick Returner
- St. Louis/Phoenix Cardinals
- Green Bay Packers
- Philadelphia Eagles
- 1986-1993
Herschel Walker
- Running Back/Kick Returner
- Dallas Cowboys
- Minnesota Vikings
- Philadelphia Eagles
- New York Giants
- 1986-1997
Lem Barney
- Cornerback/Kick Returner
- Detroit Lions
- 1967-1977
Darrien Gordon
- Kick Returner/Defensive Back
- San Diego Chargers
- Denver Broncos
- Oakland Raiders
- Atlanta Falcons
- Green Bay Packers
- 1993-2002
Mel Renfro
- Kick Returner/ Defensive Back
- Dallas Cowboys
- 1964-1977
Billy “White Shoes” Johnson
- Wide Receiver/Punt Returner
- Houston Oilers
- Atlanta Falcons
- Washington Redskins
- 1974-1988
Jon Arnett
- Running Back/Kick Returner
- Los Angeles Rams
- Chicago Bears
- 1957-1966
Larry Anderson
Kick Returner
Pittsburgh Steelers
Baltimore/Indianapolis Colts
1978-1984
Gary Anderson (Running Back)
- Running Back
- San Diego Chargers
- Tampa Bay Buccaneers
- Detroit Lions
- 1985-1993