Rocky Bleier
- Running Back
- Pittsburgh Steelers
- 1968-1980
Vince Lombardi
- Head Coach
- Los Angeles Rams
- Washington Redskins
- 1959-1969
Mercury Morris
- Running Back
- Miami Dolphins
- San Diego Chargers
- 1969-1977
Fuzzy Thurston
- Offensive Guard
- Baltimore Colts
- Green Bay Packers
- 1958-1967
Most Career Receptions by AFL Receivers
Most Career Catches by AFL Receivers
Jim Katcavage
- Defensive End
- New York Giants
- 1956-1968
Ron Johnson
- Running Back
- Cleveland Browns
- New York Giants
- 1969-1975
Hewritt Dixon
- Running Back
- Denver Broncos
- Oakland Raiders
- 1974-1990
Mark Duper
- Wide Receiver
- Miami Dolphins
- 1982-1992
LC Greenwood
- Defensive End
- Pittsburgh Steelers
- 1969-1981
Jack Kemp
- Quarterback
- Pittsburgh Steelers
- San Diego Chargers
- Los Angeles/San Diego Chargers
- Buffalo Bills
- 1957,1960-1967,1969
Frank Ryan
- Quarterback
- Los Angeles Rams
- Cleveland Rams
- Washington Redskins
- 1958-1970